top of page
16-flavors.jpg

OUR SOUL-SATISFYING
Flavors

We hand make all of our ice cream in small batches using all natural, seasonal ingredients. We're always thinking up new flavor combinations and experimenting with the classics, so this is just a sample of our menu. 

CREAMERY CLASSICS

Always available

Tahitian Vanilla

Plain ol' Vanilla? Come on now... we can do better than that!
We scrape the pulp from Tahitian Vanilla beans and soak them in vodka to create our own handmade vanilla extract. Then we churn the extract with milk, cream, eggs and sugar and, voila, an ice cream sent from Vanilla heaven is born.

Good Ole Fashioned Chocolate 

When this flavor landed at the Creamery, it had us at first bite. Homemade creamy, dark chocolate ice cream- Chocoholics- you will LOVE this one.

Mint Chocolate Chunk

Delicious, refreshing, homemade, all natural Mint Ice Cream (its green hue is drawn from a leafy vegetable!!) with chocolate chunks tossed in. One taste and we knew it was MINT to be a Creamery classic!

PeanutButterpalooza

We created the yummiest, peanut butter-iest Homemade Peanut Butter Ice Cream, tossed in a lotta Crushed Oreos and threw in handfuls of made from scratch Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups for good measure.

Hudson Cafe Coffee Crunch

To create this Creamery Top Seller- we take Hudson Café Coffee Cold Brew, hazelnuts, ground coffee beans, sugar and cream. There are no words for this jubilant java concoction...ok, maybe three words.... GIVE. US. MORE.

Cookies N Cream

Homemade Sweet Cream ice cream with lots of crushed Oreo Cookies. Simple, classic and so freaking delicious!

Brown Sugar Cookie Dough

Homemade Brown Sugar Ice Cream with tons and tons of Cookie Dough. Perfection.

Creamery Classics
woodys orange crush.jpg

SMALL BATCH

Flavors of the Month

Banana Cream Pie

D.O. Apple Crumb Pie

Death By Chocolate

Ooey Gooey Rice Krispy

Bourbon Coffee Pecan

Vegan Banana Oreo

Small Batch

586 River Road
Fair Haven, NJ 07704

732-852-2033

​

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri -Sat:

12PM to 10PM

84 1st Avenue


Atlantic Highlands, NJ

07716
732-204-2340

​

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri -Sat:

12PM to 10PM

1201 Sycamore Ave
Tinton Falls, NJ 07724
848-456-4035

​

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri-Sat:

12PM-10PM

444 Ocean Blvd N

Long Branch, NJ

07740

732-272-1098

​

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri -Sat:

12PM to 10PM

MIDDLETOWN

1500 Route 35
Unit 19
Middletown, NJ  07748

848-225-3476

​

Hours:

Sun-Thurs:

12PM to 9PM

Fri -Sat:

12PM to 10PM

®2024 NICHOLAS CREAMERY

WEBSITE CREATED BY SOUTH OF MADISON 

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
bottom of page